The judge in the case not only says that the latest evidence makes a compelling case to throw out their conviction, but he wants prosecutors to explain why the convictions shouldn’t be overturned.

A Los Angeles judge told DA Nathan Hochman to show cause as to why the brothers should not be entitled to habeas corpus relief.

The judge’s order notes that lawyers for Lyle and Erik Menendez have two pieces of evidence they say could have changed the outcome of the trial.